Publishers’ Consolidation
Since the 1980s, big American publishers have been increasingly playing in the world of big corporate capitalism: mergers, acquisitions, big investment, and big pressure on quarterly growth.
See André Schiffrin. 2010. Words and Money. Verso Press.
Since the late 1990s, the biggest publishers have become part of massive multinational media corporations.
Bertelsmann AG acquired Random House (itself already a conglomerate of smaller publishers) in 1998. Bertelsmann folded leading paperback publisher Doubleday into Random House and it became a mega-publishing company, owned by one of the largest media companies in the world.
Its biggest competitor, HarperCollins, became the flagship company of a publisher conglomerate owned by Rupert Murdoch’s News Corp.
Simon & Schuster, along with Prentice-Hall, was acquired by Paramount Communictions in 1989; Paramount was acquired by Viacom in 1994, at which time it acquired Macmillan USA. In 2005, Viacom rebranded as its former subsidiary (and prior to that, parent company), CBS Communications.
Penguin, Dorling-Kindersley and the educational division of Simon & Schuster were acquired by Pearson PLC in 1998, the world’s largest educational publisher.
The Rise of Chapters
Chapters was the result of a merger of leading Canadian chain stores Smithbooks and Coles in 1994. The Chapters brand went public with launch of superstores in 1995. Within a few years, there were over 75 superstores, and 280 small stores (Coles, Smithbooks, etc.)
The merger was approved by federal Competition Bureau because it promised to expand the book market in Canada.
Soon Chapters had over 60% of the book market — both to customers and to publishers. This allowed them to drive increasingly hard terms: discounts (48%), >120-day payment terms, <90-day returns, and an often huge returns rate.
In 1999, Chapters attempted to launch a book wholesaler called Pegasus, demanding a 50% discount; there was a government inquiry into whether this was allowable, but Chapters found itself in dire financial straits by 1999. an American buyer (Borders?) seemed likely, but not allowable under foreign ownership laws. Heather Reisman’s Indigo (which had opened superstores in 1997 in Ontario) brought about a takeover bid and merged the two companies in 2001.
The “Superstore” model (think “big box” stores like Costco, Wal-Mart)
- big (20,000 sq ft rather than 2000; 100,000 books instead of 20,000),
- an in-store cafe (Starbucks),
- bestsellers discounted 40%.
In the USA, two big chains provide a comparable model to Chapters/Indigo: Barnes & Noble, an old American Bookstore chain, began the “book superstore” model in the late 1980s. Until recently it was the largest bookseller in the world.
Borders, the #2 chain in USA, with International stores as well, went to bankruptcy proceedings in February of 2011.
All 3 chains also opened online stores by around 2000.
The fundamental problem with superstores: they flood the market, beyond actual demand, which cheapens retail market, making it difficult for anyone to compete. See Karl Seigler’s “The Emperor’s New Clothes: A Submission to the Standing Committee of the Department of Canadian Heritage on the Recent Past and the Near Future of the Book Trade in Canada.” [March 2, 2000] http://www.canadiancontent.ca/interviews/080103siegler3.pdf
The motivation is growth, which is always great for investment. But the growth is short-lived, as superstores “saturated the limited locations where books can be sold and faced the same limits to future growth that their predecessors in the malls had faced when available locations became increasingly marginal.” (Epstein 2002, p161)
As a result, the big chain stores eventually start to collapse (Borders) or contract (Chapters), and flesh out their stock with things more profitable than books (lifestyle, homewares, etc.)
Chapters’ volatility led in part to the bankruptcy of General Distribution Service—a leading book distribution agency in Canada—in 2001, and much damage to publishers. The Department of Canadian Heritage advanced grants to help ease the cashflow problem. Reasons were partly Chapters’ high rate of returns (of unsold books) and very late payment terms, but also partly GDS’ own growth and indebtedness.
Amazon
Amazon.com was founded in Seattle in 1995 on the idea that inventory (and therefore selection) could be far greater in an online store than even the largest superstore.
Amazon’s Initial Public Offering in 1997 (at the beginning of the dot-com boom) raised $1.8Billion in market capitalization, and became one of the “poster children” of the dot.com era. But the company wasn’t profitable at all in the early years, as it gradually amassed a world-beating database of customer profile information, and pioneered many Internet retail techniques:
- automated recommendations based on your purchasing profile
- wish-lists and other curation opportunities
- book reviews online
- expanding and consolidating market position by acquiring neighbouring businesses (IMDB, Alexa, Audible, BookSurge, AbeBooks, Zappos, Mobipocket, Lexcycle)
Still branded primarily as a bookstore, Amazon is an e-retailing giant, almost single-handedly re-defining how retail, warehousing, fulfillment, and web-services are offered). It operates in a dozen countries worldwide.
A few milestones:
- Search Inside the Book – 2003
- Kindle Reader – 2007
- World’s largest book retailer – 2008
- Announced that ebook sales exceeded hardcover sales – 2010
Chris Anderson’s groundbreaking article, The Long Tail (Wired 12.10, 2004) dealt largely with how Amazon had defined a new era of retail based on very low-cost inventory and near-infinite availability.
If Amazon could become the world’s most successful bookseller while still warehousing and shipping physical books, think how successful they could be if they could convert a significant portion of that business to zero-cost inventory (i.e., ebooks).
Other major players released competitive ebook platforms:
Chapters/Indigo launched Kobo, originally as a subsidiary, but quickly spun off into a separate company in 2009. Chapters/Indigo owns more than 50% of the company, Borders in the USA owns (owned?) a significant piece as well. At first an app-based system, a dedicated e-reader appeared in 2010.
Barnes & Noble released the Nook reader in 2009, and a colour version in 2010. The Nook remains the #1 competitor to Kindle.
Amazon’s market dominance (no one knows exactly what their share is, as the company is notoriously cagey with details) means they are driving innovation at all levels of the book industry, something they have done ruthlessly in recent years.
Print on Demand and Self-Publishing
Self-publishing used to be called “Vanity Publishing”—here, an author would put up a substantial amount of money to see his or her manuscript produced as an actual book. It was expensive because offset printing and binding are expensive to do unless you’re prepared to print thousands of copies. So apparently, only the vain would do this.
In the late 1990s, digital printing technology emerged as a market force. Essentially a big photocopier with a binding machine attached, a digital printer can produce a book cheaply, even only one copy at a time. The result is that it becomes economical to produce very short print runs, or even single copies “on demand” as orders come in.
Digital printing has been used to make it possible to publish niche books or books with limited sales (such as poetry); it also provides an opportunity to keep books in print longer.
More dramatically, digital printing has caused an enormous boom in self-publishing. It is now cheap—very cheap—to produce a book, and so agencies and service providers abound, and the total number of titles in circulation has skyrocketed. Numbers from “Global Books in Print” publisher R.R. Bowker show the number of “traditionally published” titles per year to be about 225,000 in the USA. In 2009, self-published titles equalled that number, and in 2010, they vastly outnumbered traditionally published books. The result is that the market for books is even more saturated than it ever was before, with more and more titles competing for our attention.
The biggest obstacle facing self-publishers is visibility and access to a market. With its enormous audience, Amazon is in a position to make self-publishers into a market force. This is a business they seem to be pursuing aggressively today.